what say-2

I believe you have read my previous article in this blog. But I got only four comments yaar. If at all you don’t like that, do write my mistakes. Or If you don’t like my name or face….I can’t help. Hahahaa…Jokes apart, here is a summary of a very old but very nice article of Mr Swaminathan (Swaminomics). But I want to warn you that, this article of Mr Swaminathan is a mixture of Gandhigiri and his economics brain.

Bihar is by far the best place in India to grow cane, a water-intensive crop. Bihar has fertile land, heavy rainfall and a high water table that can provide cheap, assured irrigation. Bihar should become the sugar-cane capital of India, producing millions of tones of ethanol. Also Cane is a very profitable crop for farmers, requiring little care and yielding high returns. After cutting, cane grows again, and can be harvested four times before requiring replanting. Cane has made western U.P. prosperous, and could make Bihar rich too.

Bihar, a state which was India’s industrial heartland in the 1950s, boasting the giant Tata complex at Jamshedpur and Dalmia-Jain complex at Rohtas. Bihar enjoyed massive public sector investment (Bokaro steel, Barauni refinery, Sindri and Barauni fertilizer plants, Heavy Engineering Corporation, Mining and Allied Machinery Corporation, coal mines). But Now Bihar is among the poorest, most misgoverned states. More Plan funds or public sector projects are not remedies. No business man wants to invest in Bihar because of the mafia extortion and kidnapping threats. Nothing can be done in against of that. Reason…. Everyone knows, Deplorable governance, Weak institutions and Criminal galore in state legislature & cabinet.

Mr. Swami Nathan suggests…”To make a legitimate business more politically and financially rewarding for the mafia than extortion.”

With oil at $ 70/barrel, ethanol is a cheap substitute for petrol and diesel. Up to 15% ethanol can be mixed with these fuels. Brazil has pioneered vehicles running on pure ethanol, which today costs half as much as petrol. Ethanol is produced in India from molasses, a by-product of sugar. In Brazil, ethanol is also produced directly from sugar cane juice: that, at today’s prices, is more profitable than the sugar-molasses-ethanol route.

But most sugar mills in Bihar are closed. Business conditions have long always been abysmal. Bihari farmers have stopped growing cane because mills lack the money to pay. No business tycoon is ready to fund on mills in a crime-ridden state even though it is a profitable business.

So, who will run ethanol mills successfully in Bihar? Only the mafia can. But first, they must be convinced that they can get more money and votes from ethanol than extortion. The mafia alone can enforce rules, so let them enforce rules for growing cane and converting it to ethanol. Let the robber barons become sugar barons, or ethanol barons. They will do so only if ethanol yields sinful profits. That, happily, seems to be the case with oil at $ 70/barrel. The political dividends look good too. Sugar cane benefits farmers and wins votes.

Isn’t it fantastic idea? How different he thinks. Isn’t it guys? After all he is Mr. Swaminathan, the great ecnomist.


6 responses

  1. Sudhakar

    It is really a nice article. I do read Newspaper daily, But I have never came across this article. May be I missed it. Thanks for making us aware of such a nice article. Also you have summarized this in very nicely.

    But dont you think this idea seems impossible to execute.

    June 19, 2007 at 1:43 PM

  2. Bihar should become a retail hub … it has huge population this huge market … and compliment the retail business with banking ….and the ethanol idea these three come together to make a deadly bihar … a super bower

    June 19, 2007 at 2:28 PM

  3. piyush

    well its a good article but it aint practically possible to convince maifia .. who will convince, how , what terms .. big problem
    n moreover this article is having more of a goody goody look … u neva thought of black marketing stuff blah blah .. i think tht gandhigiri thingy was good in movie only .. it cant hold steady in practical life … thts my point. wotcha say ?

    June 19, 2007 at 6:10 PM

  4. Pranshu

    As I have always told you, me thinks this is a very interesting and under-rated idea…a bit too fantastic but thats how dreams are and I really believe in what Mr.Swaminathan has suggested…as they say, money is the root of all evil…once this inflow of legitimate money gets going, everthing will fall in place…the common man doesnt really enjoy crime, nor do the criminals…given a choice of making a living the straight everyone would go for it…and that is what Mr.Swaminathan’s idea leads us to…desperate times seek desperate measures…but where are the people, the leaders to take these desperate measures and straighten up Bihar for good?

    June 20, 2007 at 10:47 AM

  5. Debasis

    @ Nikhil: U r quite right, but for retail, i think it will take time
    @ Piyush: Dont u think, because of these question marks only we havent moved forward much. It is the responsibilty of everyone….
    If at all one cant convice the mafias, one can stop their next mafia generation…as the sole reason is “unemployment”. if the employments will be opened by opening ethanol and sugar factories, the next robber barron can be a sugar barron

    June 22, 2007 at 1:46 PM

  6. piyush

    boss u are talking like madhavan in dil chahta hai ..

    June 24, 2007 at 8:32 PM

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s